Don't give us Perth's tallest phone tower, plead residents

21/Sep/2010

Comments: 2 readers have left a comment

Bicton resident Susanne Taylor-Rees in front of a mobile phone tower at Nedlands Golf Club... the proposed Point Walter Golf Club tower will be even bigger. Picture: Andrew Ritchie                  Bicton resident Susanne Taylor-Rees in front of a mobile phone tower at Nedlands Golf Club... the proposed Point Walter Golf Club tower will be even bigger. Picture: Andrew Ritchie Buy this photo

CONCERNED residents opposed to Telstra’s plans to build what is believed to be the tallest phone tower in Perth at Point Walter Golf Course are calling on councillors to recognise the importance of the A-Class Reserve before making their decision.

Last week it was confirmed management at the Department of Regional Development and Lands (DRDL) signed the proposed development application and returned it to the City of Melville, where it will now be processed as a valid planning application – allowing assessment and community consultation to start.

DRDL acting manager Cecelia Smith co-signed the application with a number of conditions, including that there be public consultation conducted by Telstra.

The tower is a high-impact 46-50m multi-use telecommunications monopole to be installed at Point Water Golf Course.

Bicton resident Susanne Taylor-Rees said a Telstra representative confirmed to her that the proposed tower, if erected, would be the largest in Perth.

“The Nedlands (Golf Club) tower initially started at 25m with six antennas and has since grown to 30m with in excess of 40 antennas. This proposed tower is already going to be an extra 15m to 20m taller than that at the beginning,” she said.

“Most alarming to all residents is the total ignorance by Telstra of the status of Point Walter. This is an A-Class Reserve and as such is afforded the highest level of protection for good reason, to be left for perpetuity.”

Mrs Taylor-Rees said more than 5000 local residents had signed a petition opposing the structure and were calling for the Mayor and councillors to listen to their wishes.

Another local resident, Geoff Spalding, said residents fought a campaign in 2002 over a proposed tower there and would do the same this time.

“This tower is larger and represents a real blot on the landscape,” he said.

A Telstra spokesman said the preferred location at Point Walter Golf Club best met the technical requirements with the least visual and environmental impact.

“Other options considered require multiple sites to achieve the same breadth and depth of coverage to the community,” he said.

He said Telstra would engage with the City to ascertain the necessary level of community consultation and assess any concerns expressed by the community.

City of Melville was unable to comment before deadline.


Bookmark and Share

What everyone else is thinking

adam rees

29/09/2010

People object to this tower because it is being placed in an A Class Reserve never disigned for this pupose. It is the equivilent of placing an oil rig in the middle of a marine reserve.

At the end of the day despite Telstra's assertions it is providing infrastructure for the community - Telstra is a national corporation ultimately responsible to share holders with a primary objective of making profits long term at the expense of community open space.

It has many other alternatives that should be explored but this is obviously the cheapest.

From this proposed site there are already 5 other base stations with in 3km, how close and how many will be enough?

steve

22/09/2010

Why do people object to this? Are they afraid of radio frequence (RF) radiation? Do you not realize you get a lot more RF radiation from having a mobile in your pocket/using a mobile all day, by using a WIFI home network and bluetooth devices, as well as cordless phones in the home? I'm sure most of the people objecting would complain if there were dropouts in their mobile conversations, but they just don't want to look at a great big tower. Would it be better that there were X amount of towers, one for each carrier or just one tower for all carriers?

Share your thoughts in 60 seconds!

Members : login to comment


 

Wednesday 23 May 2012

  • Min 9°C
  • Max 21°C

Thursday

  • 5 - 21°C

Friday

  • 7 - 22°C

Most Popular Articles


community digital epaper link

Latest Competitions



Win a share in $20,000 of Coles groceries Go>:


driveway comp

Fuel up with Driveway Go>:



Win a romantic getaway for two at Fremantle's finest!  Go>:


Win a double pass to the Good Food & Wine show Go>:


Win tickets to FRAGILE  Go>:



Featured Video Clips


2012 RAAF Pearce Air Show promo



Community Newspaper Group Photographer Jon Hewson goes for a spin in a P/C-9A Hawk to help promote the 2012 RAAF Pearce Air Show, held on May 19 and 20. Video, images and editing by Jon Hewson.



Circus performer Brenna Day



Circus performer Brenna Day talks about her career and upcoming performances in the Perth International Burlesque Festival. Video, images and editing by Matthew Poon.


See more videos 

email subscribe linkHBF junior sports hero
Deliver our newspapers linkCommunityPix banner linkSolahart